A historical investigator, known for his work locating the site of Thoreau’s cabin at Walden Pond, was hired, and the original foundation of the Shadwell house was thought to have been discovered. A replica house was built at the location in 1961, filled with antiques, and opened to the public.
But two years later, the Thomas Jefferson Memorial Foundation, owners of Monticello, took possession of the site, and shut it down, claiming that the house was not historically accurate.